2021.07.14 14:10

No right to appeal and mass detentions: Lithuania's new migrant laws draw criticism

LRT.lt2021.07.14 14:10

The Lithuanian parliament passed a package of new laws on Tuesday curbing the rights of asylum seekers. A former Constitutional Court judge has said the legislation brazenly violates Lithuania's constitution, while political leaders defend the measures as expedient.

Lithuania has experienced a spike of irregular migration in recent months, detaining some 1,700 people who have crossed the border from Belarus. Vilnius has accused the Minsk government of facilitating migrant smuggling and using migrants as a “weapon”.

Read more: Lithuania adopts law restricting rights of irregular migrants

The laws, adopted under a fast-track procedure, allow, among other things, to keep irregular migrants in detention for up to six months.

The legislation also limits the right of appeal for rejected asylum-seekers. Migrants will not be allowed to challenge unfavourable rulings of lower courts at higher-instance courts. Moreover, they can be deported while their appeals are under consideration.

Former Constitutional Court chairman Dainius Žalimas has called the measures “legislative nihilism”.

“Besides all the other possibly anti-constitutional restrictions on human rights, the parliament today deprived asylum seekers of their right to appeal,” he said in a social media post on Tuesday night.

“It would be hard to find a more blatant violation of the constitution done on purpose rather than out of ignorance,” he insisted, adding that the legislation would be scrapped, if it were challenged at the Constitutional Court.

Several non-governmental organisations have said the decision to detain migrants violates Lithuania's international obligations, as well as the rights of the asylum seekers.

“The law is a potential human rights violation, and it does not correspond to EU directives,” Eglė Samuchovaitė of the Lithuanian Red Cross told the news agency Reuters. “It enshrines the current bad situation in Lithuania's detention centers in law and leaves vulnerable people in an even more vulnerable situation.”

The Lithuanian Red Cross, which is organising volunteers to work with the detained migrants, has said that some 40 percent of them belong to vulnerable groups, such as mothers with children, unaccompanied minors, or victims of violence.

Viktorija Čmilytė-Nielsen, the liberal speaker of the parliament, said on Tuesday that some criticisms of the legislation might be justified, but defended it nonetheless.

“Lithuania is facing an unprecedented threat when migrants are used as a tool to put pressure on both Lithuania and the European Union,” she told reporters before the vote.

“Today, we stated in the parliament that this influx of migrants is not a natural wave of migration, it is an element in a hybrid attack by the Belarusian regime,” Čmilytė-Nielsen told LRT TV on Tuesday night. “And we adopted decisions that simplify and speed up the processing of asylum applications, and also allow to restrict certain rights when an extreme situation is declared in the country.”

The Lithuanian government declared a state-level emergency (ekstremali situacija) last week, saying it would help to deal with the influx of irregular migrants more efficiently.

Prime Minister Ingrida Šimonytė has said that Lithuanian institutions are still capable of dealing with the migrants, but may be overwhelmed if the flows intensify. She conceded that, in such an event, Lithuania might not be able to fully ensure the migrants' rights.

“The government is surely intent on ensuring the rights of people who have illegally crossed the Lithuanian border, taking into account special assistance that might be needed by vulnerable groups, children or pregnant women. The government is not interested in violating anyone's rights, but we need to look at the situation soberly and it can happen – which is not the case at the moment – that we will not be able physically to ensure all the rights to everyone,” Šimonytė told reporters on Tuesday.

She said the new legislation defines a “basic” level of rights that should be maintained, while “we will try to make sure that people's dignity is respected, even if they turned up in the Republic Lithuania uninvited”.

Meanwhile, President Gitanas Nausėda has commented that the legal situations of asylum seekers should be resolved in a way “that we would at least not promote a new influx of migrants”.

“In this case, we need to regulate those relations by respecting human rights. But, on the other hand, we cannot become a walk-through yard, [...] which would mean that these people would not stay long in Lithuania and would move further, and this way we would only exacerbate the problem across the EU,” Nausėda said at a media event on his two-year presidency.

Read more: Six years ago Lithuania turned a blind eye. Now it is asking for EU's solidarity tackling migration

Mums svarbus tikslumas ir sklandi tekstų kalba. Jei pastebėjote klaidų, praneškite